Compressor Types and TCO

Picture this: A car on cruise control glides efficiently down the highway, conserving fuel and reducing wear. Now imagine the same car constantly flooring it, then slamming on the brakes. Which vehicle do you think has a longer lifecycle?

Your HVAC system works the same way. Variable capacity compressors are the cruise control of HVAC—smooth, efficient, and built for the long haul.

COMPRESSOR TYPES IN RTU HVAC APPLICATIONS

On/Off Compressors

On/off compressors are like stop-and-go driving. They’re either running at full capacity or completely off. While simple and inexpensive, the constant cycling leads to inefficiency, uneven temperatures, and a shorter lifespan.

2-Step Compressors

With two distinct capacity levels (e.g., 100% and 66%), 2-step compressors improve on the on/off design. They reduce cycling and provide better control over temperature and humidity, making them a reasonable choice for moderate performance needs.

Variable Capacity Compressors (Digital Scroll)

Variable capacity compressors are the cruise control of HVAC systems. They smoothly adjust capacity to match demand, delivering exceptional efficiency and comfort. With a turndown capability as low as 10%, they excel in part-load conditions, ensuring your system works only as hard as it needs to.

Even better, these compressors boast industry-leading reliability, with failure rates as low as 1 in 200 over five years—compared to 1 in 30 for cycling models. By minimizing starts and stops, they extend system longevity while reducing wear and tear. For most RTU applications, they offer the best balance of performance, reliability, and value.

Variable Speed Compressors (Inverter Duty)

Variable speed compressors represent the cutting edge of efficiency and precision. Unlike other technologies, they modulate both the motor and compressor speed, allowing them to operate at optimal levels even during off-peak days. With their ability to match demand precisely, they provide the highest energy efficiency in low-load scenarios, delivering significant savings over time.

While their turndown capability is generally limited to around 30%, their fully modulating design ensures smooth operation, particularly in conditions with fluctuating loads. To maintain reliability, it’s essential to incorporate a controls flush sequence that ramps up the compressor periodically, ensuring proper oil return. When paired with advanced control strategies, variable speed compressors are an excellent choice for applications requiring precise temperature and humidity control.

WHY COMPRESSOR CHOICE MATTERS FOR TOTAL COST OF OWNERSHIP

When it comes to Total Cost of Ownership (TCO), compressor selection plays a critical role. While on/off compressors offer the lowest upfront cost, their inefficiencies, frequent repairs, and shorter lifespan drive up costs over time.

2-step compressors offer a moderate improvement but still leave energy and maintenance savings on the table. Variable capacity compressors, with their superior efficiency, reliability, and part-load performance, deliver the best overall value for TCO. They minimize energy consumption, reduce maintenance expenses, and extend equipment life—key factors that lower operational costs year after year.

Variable speed compressors can also be an excellent TCO strategy, especially in applications where precise control and maximum energy savings during variable load conditions are critical.

Ultimately, investing in the right compressor technology is a strategic decision that pays dividends over the entire life of the system.

Need help getting your building temperature under control? Reach out to your BCS Representative to find your custom solution. 

Contact Us

Learn more about our services and offerings.

Service Requests

Our team is ready to assist. Please use one of the options below to submit your service request:

Warranty Claims

You can now submit warranty claims online via our fast and convenient online warranty process.

Become an Expert

Become an expert in building intelligence. Save money by lowering the total cost of ownership of your facility equipment. Sign up to receive helpful tips, tricks, and insights to facility management from people who’ve dealt with it all.

Become an Expert

Become an expert in building intelligence. Save money by lowering the total cost of ownership of your facility equipment. Sign up to receive helpful tips, tricks, and insights to facility management from people who’ve dealt with it all.